Reflections on Personal Values and Policing

Join us for this summer worship service with invited guest Chris Mason reflecting on notions of mercy, sacrifice, redemption and humility, facilitated by Jordan Young. We share our offering plate with Festival on the Green in support of their upcoming one July 12-18 on the Middlebury Town Green following St Stephen’s Peasant Market on Sat July 11.

Video Recording of the Service

Transcript of the Sermon

Poem by Anne Sexton

JESUS, THE ACTOR, PLAYS THE HOLY GHOST

Oh, Mother,

Virgin Mother,

before the gulls take me out the door,

marry me.

Marry me not to a goat

but to a goddess.

What?

You say it can not be done!

 

Then I will do it!

I wash the crows

but they do not whiten.

I push out the desk,

pulling it from its roots.

I shave the caterpillar

but he is only a worm.

I take the yellow papers

and I write on them

but they crumble like men’s ashes.

I take the daisy

and blow my heart into it

but it will not speak.

 

Oh, Mother,

marry me,

before the gulls take me out the door.

will I marry the dark earth,

the thief of the daylight?

Will I marry a tree

and only wave my hands at you

from your front yard?

Oh, mother,

oh, mother

you marry me,

save me from the cockroach,

weave me into the sun.

There will be bread.

There will be water.

My elbows will be salt.

 

Oh, Mary,

Gentle Mother,

open the door and let me in.

A bee has stung your belly with faith.

Let me float in it like a fish.

Let me in! Let me in!

I have been born many times, a false Messiah,

but let me be born again

into something true.

Sermon

I was asked to do a reflection on living my personal values and policing. I suppose I should preface this by saying that I am a police officer.

My mother died last May.

I wasn’t able to make it back to England in time to see her before she passed.

By the time I heard she was ill, she’d already lost consciousnes – she never regained consciousness, so she wouldn’t have known I was there.

I would have liked to be there all the same.

The last time I saw her, she didn’t know who I was – she didn’t know who anybody was by that point. She wasn’t speaking, though she would sometimes dance if there was music. 

I thought I’d said goodbye on that visit – but I hadn’t.

I thought I’d grieved – but I hadn’t.

My mother lost a child before I was born – a daughter. She lived for a few days. 

After that, my mother was so deeply depressed for such a long time, it was uncertain whether she’d make it. When she did emerge, after many months, she had an affair with a married man and I was the result.

Her salvation.

But I had such severe respiratory problems, that for several years my life hung by a thread. I try to imagine sometimes how afraid she must have been holding me while I was gasping on those long nights, but I don’t think I really can.  

On this last visit – for the funeral – I stayed with my brother. There was a little flint church just a few minutes away – St Mary Magdalene. I spent a lot of time in the garden of that church thinking about my mother. 

On of those afternoons I wrote this:

Back when buttercups were yellow

and all things green were green

and I wore white wool

knitted by hands

that held my hands

my head

in all its earnestness

nestled

you whispered

throbbing like a pigeon

into the soft soul of me

my treasure

I will not see you crowned

the blossom of you

unadorned beneath my breast

unbriared

unbound by iron or gold

and your chest shall rise

with breath and rest

uncloaked

unpurpled

and the brown burrowing

truth of you shall not

know fear

 

And I believed

that she believed

and I believe that still

 

I wonder, in those moments of fear, what my mother would have given to have me live. What would she have been willing to sacrifice for her values. Her values were simple – really, I think, just the one overwhelming need that eclipsed all others – to have her child survive – something sacred for which she would have been willing to give up everything of herself.

What are we prepared to give for those people who justify our existence – who make it meaningful – who are able somehow to make us feel, for a moment, not alone?

And how much peril should we strive to protect them from?

While love compels us to protect, there is always peril in love, and what makes it true, makes it dangerous – makes us vulnerable. 

The wholeness and the brokenness are knit so close together.

How do we accept the death that exists within the love?

I used to talk a lot about facing my fears – I was convinced it was essential for authenticity and for happiness – and happiness was very important to me back then. 

So, I ventured into the forest at night – I danced naked in lightning storms – I dove into the sea in Winter – I scaled cliffs.

And, I was convinced, I faced my fear of death.

I was convinced I dutifully acknowledged that every moment – every shred of bliss – tumbles inevitably into the void.

I thought I faced it with equanimity – that I embraced it. But what was I really prepared to lose? What was I really prepared to sacrifice for my values? 

I chose a life of service and perhaps, in many ways, I do realize my values through my work, but what does it truly mean to live one’s values? What loss am I actually willing to bear? And what loss am I prepared to impose?

When I was young, I travelled. While in Nepal, I got sick, and convalescing in my hotel room for several days, I watched a family in the adjacent lot breaking rocks. The entire family, from the children barely walking, carrying the small pieces, to the adults wielding the hammers – every day, breaking rocks. 

How many days, I wonder – how much life spent smashing stone?

I returned to the US – and here I am, living my life. A life in which I face danger – have people screaming at me, threatening to kill me, or telling me I’m scum. 

All those hours spent with people cognitively fractured, at the hospital or under the bridge. Examining corpses – the decomposing bodies and shattered skulls – and the hours spent with the grief of those bereft.

And doing so much of it exhausted.

Was that living my values? Was that sacrifice?

And my daughter, in high school, having her friends speak with casual righteousness of the evil of police – her family – her father – evil. And her, evil by association. Her shame.

Was that sacrifice? 

There was a period a few years ago when it was very common for people to have lawn signs proclaiming their rectitude. There was one I remember in particular which bore Dr King’s words:

Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.

The sign stood outside a house worth at least $700,000.

Every time I passed that sign, I thought of that family smashing rocks in Nepal all those years ago, and I wondered how many children breaking rocks that $700,000 represents – how much life was woven into that wealth. How much of our wealth is built upon that poverty? 

Arguably, I suppose, all of it.

It strikes me, the only appropriate term for a global economic system predicated upon such staggering disparities is slavery.

So here I stand, living my life of service, a participant in slavery – my comfort and security purchased by it.

And beyond that, I have money invested in the market – I have a pension. Do those financial entanglements make me a slave owner? By such a standard, I imagine almost everyone in this building is a slave owner.

Where is the justice? What sacrifice is demanded by such relentless and extreme horror? Can I really claim to be living my values, charging my Prius in a garage so much larger than the living space of most people in the World – eating figs – going to the gym?

Perhaps I am living my personal values in policing – a little: praising the artwork of the teenage girl who moments before had locked herself in the bathroom with a knife.

Talking about exploring tidepools with a woman in crisis in my cruiser as I drove them to their apartment in Rutland because they weren’t welcome with their family – because they were too disruptive.

Holding the drug dealer accountable for selling fentanyl to the father who overdosed.

Standing between the woman and her abuser – as I wasn’t able to do as a child – as I wasn’t able to do for my mother.

And standing between the child and the person who would use them for their gratification – who would make that child a thing.

So many people made into things.

Simone Weil wrote: Among human beings, only the existence of those we love is truly recognized. Belief in the existence of other human beings as such is love.

I do try, in my work, to recognize the existence of other human beings. I do try to love. 

But all of this – 17 years of this – and some of it truly momentous in its quiet profundity – arguably utterly negligible within the context of that broader injustice that I do nothing to remedy.  

I’m left with a lot of questions.

Am I a good person? 

And if I really am, sometimes, genuinely, a good person, how does that goodness measure up against the wickedness? The atrocities I’ve committed not loving as I should? The sin of all I’ve done and all I’ve failed to do?

Does it even make sense to think in terms of personal goodness – and is the guilt itself a form of hubris? A sense of responsibility rooted in the misguided notion that I can, through my paltry agency, cure the World’s sickness. A very Protestant form of confidence in the significance of the individual – a very American form of confidence.    

And, if I am impotent, should I at least be grateful for my privilege? Monstrous as that is, perhaps it would be even more monstrous not to be.

Or should I beg for forgiveness? Forgiveness for my stubborn, still very much not accepted, fear of loss – and my unwillingness to sacrifice the things I truly cherish?

But who would I beg? What God forgives the sins of atheists – and even if there were such a God, would I want their forgiveness? Would I deserve it?

Perhaps it’s God who should kneel.

Perhaps that’s what God does – and perhaps there is grace in the act of forgiving – grace in forgiving God.

Or perhaps true grace lies in refusing to forgive – in denying God absolution for their sins – and, by that refusal, condemning myself to a life of alienation from their love. Perhaps embracing that atrocity – embracing that unspeakable aloneness – is the sacrifice – perhaps it is that which is truly demanded by my values. 

Here’s another one from the churchyard:

In the garden where I wept

Christ came to me

between the fieldstone wall

and the blossoming fig

and knelt

and begged

for forgiveness

I lifted

his face

and refused

penitent crowned and cradled

he remained

until all my grief was spent

and when he rose

and walked away

I whispered

too faint to hear

return to me

my love

and I will absolve you

I will kiss your forehead

and weave daisies in your hair

I will love you

as you should be loved

and know for a moment more

what it means to be

not alone